Mio Akiyama School Festival Ver. - Max Factory vs upLark vs ALTER

Posted by Jacki [www] 

I want to do a comparative study of 3 different figures. Mio Akiyama School Festival verion.
A different depiction of Mio in the same outfit by 3 different manufacturers.
Keep in mind, I don't own any of these figures. I am interested in one of them and am trying to figure out which.
I'll be inspecting each figure individually and doing evaluating each on a point basis. +1 for a pro, and -1 for a con. They will each start with 5 points.

Let's begin in order of release date.

Mouseover = load notes.
Mio Akiyama School Festival Ver. - Max Factory vs upLark vs ALTER
Mouseover = load notes.
Mio Akiyama School Festival Ver. - Max Factory vs upLark vs ALTER
Mouseover = load notes.
Mio Akiyama School Festival Ver. - Max Factory vs upLark vs ALTER

Mio Akiyama manufactured by upLark.
-sculpted by Ani and Mesuka
-released 3/2010
-7800 yen (about 92$)
-1/8 scale - 7.8 inches tall
Pros
+ already released +1
+ interchangeable faces +1
+ the only one actually looking like shes playing +1

Cons
-Not such a great face sculpt -1
-Unnatural pose -1
---------------------------------------------
Total Score = 6.
Not bad.
Side comment = The sculpt of the face just isn't up to par for me. And her pose, I tried doing it IRL and it felt unnatural!

Mouseover = load notes.
Mio Akiyama School Festival Ver. - Max Factory vs upLark vs ALTER
Mouseover = load notes.
Mio Akiyama School Festival Ver. - Max Factory vs upLark vs ALTER

Mio Akiyama manufactured by ALTER
-sculpted by Numakura Toshiaki
-released 9/2010 (THIS MONTH!!)
-7140 yen (about 85$)
-1/8 scale - 8.2 inches tall
Pros
+ cheapest of the three +1
+ released this month! no chance of inflation due to rarity! +1
+ taller than upLarks +1 (Max Factory's is a 1/7 scale)
+ cutest face of the 3 +1
+ dress is best shown off with her figure +1

Cons
- The hair is not appealing from the back, very flat -1
- strange skintone -1
- weird skinny right hand (check that shit!! )-1
--------------------------------------------
Total Score = 7
Good!
Side comment = I really like the Alter version. I'm tempted to go find her now!

Mouseover = load notes.
Mio Akiyama School Festival Ver. - Max Factory vs upLark vs ALTER
Mouseover = load notes.
Mio Akiyama School Festival Ver. - Max Factory vs upLark vs ALTER

Mio Akiyama manufactured by Max Factory
-sculpted by Nakayaman
-released 1/2011
-7800 yen (about 92$)
-1/7 scale - 9 inches tall
Pros
+ shes a 1/7! Huge! +1
+ embelishment of the skirt! love it! +1
+ guitar wire wrapped around is great! +1
+ best hair sculpt of the 3 +1


Cons
-I dont care for the hand over the face -1
- release date. Really far away! -1
---------------------------------------------
Total Score = 7
also Good.
Side Comment = All in all, Max Factory's is simply stunning. Obviously the best of the 3. But as collectors we all have individual wants and her drawbacks are unfortunatly are my peevs.

**************************
My decision? I'm tight on money at the moment. So I can't really afford to fo and find the ALTER version.
So what am I going to do?
I really don't know. upLark's is out of the way obviously. I think I shall wait and and see user pics of ALTER's version and then make my decision.
What do you all think?
Which one is your favorite?


  •  
    Akirai in Asia
    2010/09/09 12:12
    Registered on 2010/06/21. Tenshi
     

    Your comparison is mostly based on opinions, like "Cutest face of the 3" in the Alter Mio. True that it is your review and it is all based on your thoughts, but some of the pros and cons are based on your opinions. However, that's ok, after all, it is your comparison, not mine ^^;
    Personally, I'm not a Mio fan (Least Favorite K-On girl. Favorite is Ritsu). However, if I were to choose from the three, I'd say go for Alter's. You clearly love that version, and she does have the cheapest price, a definite plus if you're short on cash! I say go for the Alter, but in the end it's your decision ^^;

    •  
      Jacki in USA [www]
      2010/09/09 12:15
      Registered on 2010/07/15. College Student and performer
       

      I dont have much to go off of other than opinion. A comparison of price, release date and size is rather boring.
      If Ritsu is your favorite I'll assume you have Max Factory's gym uniform figure pre-ordered? I'm also considering that one too.

      •  
        Akirai in Asia
        2010/09/09 12:18
        Registered on 2010/06/21. Tenshi
         

        Haha, sadly, not yet. Not enough $$$ T_T Need some more part time jobs!
        Also, good luck choosing the most suited Mio figure :)

  •  
    Nodarg in United States
    2010/09/09 12:13
    Registered on 2010/09/04. Student
     

    I'd say go for the Max Factory one... but that's just the one that I like the most. The hair on the ALTER one looks really strange. It's up to you though. Good luck!

    •  
      Jacki in USA [www]
      2010/09/09 12:16
      Registered on 2010/07/15. College Student and performer
       

      The hair on the Alter one reminds me of the Mio Figma. Which is why I didn't get the mio figma. XD

  •  
    jowy in philippines
    2010/09/09 13:05
    Registered on 2008/01/23. I can say "HENSHIN" & do "CAST-OFF"
     

    Fig # 3 was so cool..badly i don't have any figmas yet XP

  •  
    2010/09/09 13:06
    Registered on 2009/05/26.
     

    I have upLark ver.
    Got it from local store which cost me less then 40 USD, and very satisfied with the colouring, face and posture.

    •  
      Jacki in USA [www]
      2010/09/09 13:11
      Registered on 2010/07/15. College Student and performer
       

      For that price I'd snap up the upLark version too.
      It's not a bad figure at all.

    •  
      CloudStrife-xx in Canada
      2011/10/06 13:16
      Registered on 2011/04/08. Architecture Student
       

      Uh, any chance you could buy one and send it my way???

  •  
    Nyxia in New York [www]
    2010/09/09 13:12
    Registered on 2008/05/10. Editor
     

    I was having the same debate between MF's and Alter's For me I really love MF's pose and outfit although the outfit does look a little less like what it's supposed to. I'd say Alter's is more accurate, but to me MF's one is just more appealing. While I don't like how she hides her face I also gotta say I do like it because to me it's really cute. The way she holds or rather hides behind her bass doesn't bother me either. So yeah I decided on MF's in the end. Although both Alter and MF's one are good choices or so I'd think (can't really say for sure until they're released).

  •  
    suteki in Australia
    2010/09/09 13:15
    Registered on 2009/07/17. Student/Ashikabi
     

    I like the max factory version, it seems to evoke some emotion when you look at it.
    I reckon it clearly shows Mio's personality

  •  
    Valegon in Texas, USA [www]
    2010/09/09 13:24
    Registered on 2010/04/11. Windows Tech and Anime Addict (read: nerd)
     

    I preordered the MaxFactory one the day it was available. By far its my favorite above all the others. I knew that I wanted this figure since the moment I saw images of it way back before it was even colored.

    The fact that she's hiding her face behind her hand is something I kind of like, you don't see it much. Her embarrassed look is so cute it makes me want to tease her more... the fact that Ritsu is one of my favorite K-ON! characters is probably a reason for that.

  •  
    Nigoki in Australia
    2010/09/09 13:43
    Registered on 2010/09/01. Software Engineer
     

    Definitely the Max Factory; it's beautiful, and reflects her personality perfectly.

  •  
    Vinn in PA
    2010/09/09 14:52
    Registered on 2010/03/12. Nendo Crazed at the moment~
     

    I have both Alter and MF ver. on pre-order. I think the slim right hand problem on Alter's ver. won't be so bad once I have it in front of me. :P

  •  
    cryptonics in Florida [www]
    2010/09/09 15:13
    Registered on 2010/08/31. hobbyist
     

    I've got a preorder in for the Max Factory version. Off the three it strikes me as the most "moe"

  •  
    silkhat in Singapore [www]
    2010/09/09 15:24
    Registered on 2010/04/18. Puella Magi
     

    get the one from Max Factory 8D
    it looks the best compared to ALter and UpLark :/
    and the hair looks waay better than Alter's

  •  
    JakeTheFake in Kuala Lumpur , Malaysia [www]
    2010/09/09 16:02
    Registered on 2009/01/02. Supernatural Alien Student
     

    i can't help but say that the more farther to the right the more Moe Mio is . Max Factory version is very Moe indeed but I'll think of having the Alter version as well ^_^ .

    Would like to see this Figure comparison once again since its very handy on choosing which figure is the best .

  •  
    EXkurogane in Malaysia [www]
    2010/09/09 16:39
    Registered on 2010/04/24. Student; CEO of Anime Merchandise Hijacking Org....
     

    I'm also spoilt for choice. Uplark's is difficult to find (i would have preferred her over Alter's as i prefer 1/8 scale, because i want her to join in my Haruhi Gekisou band!, but damn Max Factory make her 1/7!!)

  •  
    PHA66ET in in sauna house with Mugi
    2010/09/09 16:54
    Registered on 2010/09/09. Weeaboo and lover of horses
     

    Moe Moe Kyuuun~~~ nyaaaha ^______________^

  •  
    otakudepot in South Florida - USA. [www]
    2010/09/10 02:31
    Registered on 2010/04/04. Web Tech.
     

    I'm torn between the Alter and Max Factory versions. I prefer the look of Mio a bit more in the MF version but as I'm a guitarist I can't help but be bothered by the lower quality job they did in replicating her bass.

    May not bug most people but its something I see every time I look at that figure. (Missing pickup pole pieces and strangely shaped headstock)

  •  
    superunature in USA
    2010/09/14 05:03
    Registered on 2010/09/14. Student
     

    Uplark:
    pro: already available +1
    cons: ugly face -1
    interchangeable face -1 (its a collector item not a toy)
    bootleg exists -1 (super ugly)
    don't look like mio in the anime -1
    Total:2
    Alter
    pro:cheapest +1
    cute face +1
    cute pose +1
    best overall color +1
    made by alter thus greatly detailed +1
    cons:hair looks like tentacles -1
    Total:9
    Max factory
    Pro: cute face +1
    Cute pose +1
    nice hair +1
    max factory makes high quality figures +1
    very nice wrap-around detail +1
    cons: not released for many months -1
    prefers 1/7 scale figure -.5
    total 8.5
    ----------------------------------------------
    uplark one is totally out of question, definately not getting that.
    Already pre-ordered the alter one and can't wait for her to be released
    I pre-ordered max factory ritsu one too though that has very little detail compared to the mio one. and the alter yui (second shipment)
    anyways.....the alter mio better have shimapantsu or Ill cry =(
    -----------------------------------------------
    I like alter azusa, great pose, great hair, neko mimi accessorie,good price, good base. her face is just a tad strange.
    from the picture I think Alter yui looks really awlsome and can't wait for it to be re-released. but from other people's review, she appears to be wearing....black panties? o-o
    lol nyways, from the wave 1/10 scale line up, the mio and yui looks really good and retails for a great price (3980yen), azusa and mugi looks decent too, however ritsu looked little bit wierd, they made her head a little bit too sharp. and nendoroids are cute too just short ritsu for my collection (missed last release) =(.
    soon ill be spending four-digits on this serie alone lol....

  •  
    superunature in USA
    2010/09/14 05:07
    Registered on 2010/09/14. Student
     

    I perfer 1/8* scale figures as that is what most my figures are, and it looks wierd when I display them together that the 1/7 is bigger.


Latest Posts
Currently being read