Manga Haruhi Suzumiya Vol. 3 PAGE RIPPED!! TwT

Posted by Echotoyo 

My little cousin discovered ripped pages in the Vol.3 of the Haruhi manga . . . I thought my cousin was messing with me . . . and to my shock there "was" o_o" . . . . [sigh] . . . . . this is the first time I seen such an incident . . . . "how can this be!?!?! TwT"

was wondering . . . does anyone have a similar scenario?

Mouseover = load notes.
Manga Haruhi Suzumiya Vol. 3 PAGE RIPPED!! TwT

The start of the incident . . .

Mouseover = load notes.
Manga Haruhi Suzumiya Vol. 3 PAGE RIPPED!! TwT

how the rip appear as . . .

Mouseover = load notes.
Manga Haruhi Suzumiya Vol. 3 PAGE RIPPED!! TwT

surprisingly to see behind the next page is the repair work they did . . . though not as bad bit still painful to see a tape repair -__-"

Mouseover = load notes.
Manga Haruhi Suzumiya Vol. 3 PAGE RIPPED!! TwT

another view of how the rip is overall . . .

The rip page just to find it in a manga is very sad TwT . . . oh and it's not just this page that is ripped 3 more pages after this one had the same identical problem and in the same location on the page

  •  
    Maccrage in Canada
    2010/11/30 12:14
    Registered on 2010/10/27. Graphic Designer
     

    If it was a straight tear down the page it would make some sense...but this one has a pattern. Really really weird.

  •  
    Yukimos in Under your bed [www]
    2010/11/30 12:16
    Registered on 2010/09/06. Game Store Person
     

    Thats crazy! I just checked mine and its not like that. Maybe it was just a certain run of it?

  •  
    2010/11/30 12:18
    Registered on 2008/08/05. Figure Collector/Student
     

    Just checked my issue and it doesn't have that problem. Very strange indeed with that pattern.

  •  
    Marx-Taich0u in Please dun stalk me D:
    2010/11/30 12:44
    Registered on 2010/10/29. Sugar with a side of coffee
     

    Looks like one of those jagged scissors. I don't think printing presses use THAT huge of a jagged-edged cutter tho. :\ Must be something outside the publishing place.

  •  
    Angry Marine in Battlebarge Litany of Lita...
    2010/11/30 12:47
    Registered on 2010/07/29. Adeptus Astartes Horribilis
     

    i have about 400 plus manga and so far only encountered one error which was negligible. You can always end it back to the bookstore and request another.

  •  
    Sakyosa in Florida [www]
    2010/11/30 12:51
    Registered on 2010/01/26. Student
     

    I'm pretty sure this is just a simple defect with manufacturing. I find it highly unlikely that a human would rip the paper in that precise pattern. o_o
    I've had this happen to me with a photography magazine once. The paper was oddly separated in that exact same pattern.

  •  
    Yaku in California, USA [www]
    2010/11/30 13:45
    Registered on 2008/08/27. Student, part-time slave
     

    Seems like a teen with too much time in their hands and some stationary at hand... Rarely I don't check the manga and it has printing issues, like pages stuck together (they weren't cut) or very faded ink. Fortunately it's not usual from most publishers.

    If you bought it recently and still have the receipt, exchange it. If not, let's make a voodoo doll for the person who cut this >:D (lol just kid)

  •  
    Lightning Sabre in Vancouver [www]
    2010/11/30 13:54
    Registered on 2007/08/30. Prepress Operator, 触手 wrangler, H-Man
     

    Ahaha! I'm not laughing at your misfortune... I'm laughing at the fact that I KNOW why this happens now because I work at a press. Not a manga press mind you, but after observing the things at the press I work at, I totally understand what happened here.

    It's not a rip. It's more like an overlap of one paper roll running out and the next one starting. Just imagine a huge roll of toilet paper and when that runs out they have to put in another roll so that it can keep going without stopping the print. So unfortunately you were the unlucky recipient who got a copy when the roll of paper was just about to run out... I'd take it to where you bought it from and exchange with a better one.

    •  
      microgamer2vs2 in Eugene, OR [www]
      2010/11/30 14:11
      Registered on 2010/07/21. Student, Church Cantor, RBN Author
       

      LOL! So instead of reprinting they decided to tape it up?

      •  
        Lightning Sabre in Vancouver [www]
        2010/11/30 14:31
        Registered on 2007/08/30. Prepress Operator, 触手 wrangler, H-Man
         

        Well it's not a matter of reprinting ^^; I guess when they moved on to the new rolls they forgot to check if it affected any of the books and this one got through. I don't work right at the press, so I can't say if all presses check when this happens.

        I should post what my workplace is like one day ^^;;;

        •  
          microgamer2vs2 in Eugene, OR [www]
          2010/11/30 14:57
          Registered on 2010/07/21. Student, Church Cantor, RBN Author
           

          Oh. I was thinking it was some random person's handiwork at trying to fix it. Are the paper rolls connected together by some kind of tape? My initial reasoning was that this book couldn't have been the ones that "got through" because if someone applied tape in attempts to fix it, then someone noticed it was wrong. If the jagged edges of the paper rolls are held together with that tape, then it makes more sense.

          •  
            Lightning Sabre in Vancouver [www]
            2010/11/30 15:03
            Registered on 2007/08/30. Prepress Operator, 触手 wrangler, H-Man
             

            I don't think there's any tape involved but I can't be so sure since I don't work right at the press. I think they're somehow connected with many rollers that when it's time to switch it's supposed to run seamlessly. If they actually noticed that this had the jagged edges, they'd just throw away this copy ^^; I wonder if the tape fix comes from the shop where it was bought from. I'll ask one of the pressmen here one day, lol.

          •  
            Lightning Sabre in Vancouver [www]
            2010/11/30 15:31
            Registered on 2007/08/30. Prepress Operator, 触手 wrangler, H-Man
             

            My mistake... They do use tape in the splicer to connect the two separate rolls together. I saw the rolls of masking-like tape on each machine just now...

    •  
      Echotoyo in Toronto
      2010/11/30 14:14
      Registered on 2010/11/01. Graphic Designer
       

      now that you mention about it . . . yeah it would seem to be the case . . . [sigh] . . . well I won't be able to exchange it . . . would have to be a little more thorough next time when I purchace my manga in the future . . . but wow I was unfortunate :p

      •  
        Lightning Sabre in Vancouver [www]
        2010/11/30 14:32
        Registered on 2007/08/30. Prepress Operator, 触手 wrangler, H-Man
         

        Ah... That's too bad that you can't exchange it =/ But at least the print is still there instead of a complete rip/missing pages. This is also the first time I've seen something like this for a manga...

    •  
      Dysnomia in Singapore [www]
      2010/11/30 14:49
      Registered on 2010/02/09. Digital Media Student
       

      Ah yes, I kinda learned about this at one of my pre-print production lessons, I would imagine the roll of paper ever runs out there would be some sort of process gone through to tape together the new roll of paper into a seamless piece of paper but.. ah. You know. >-<

      •  
        Lightning Sabre in Vancouver [www]
        2010/11/30 14:55
        Registered on 2007/08/30. Prepress Operator, 触手 wrangler, H-Man
         

        Oh! A fellow comrade! Yes, there's basically a machine called a splicer that puts these 2 different rolls together. And when one runs out, the next roll will continue the run seamlessly... At least for the press, not for the product.

        •  
          Dysnomia in Singapore [www]
          2010/11/30 15:20
          Registered on 2010/02/09. Digital Media Student
           

          It's my first time seeing this sort of thing tho. Interesting that it's in this sort of ^^^^ shape.

          •  
            Lightning Sabre in Vancouver [www]
            2010/11/30 15:30
            Registered on 2007/08/30. Prepress Operator, 触手 wrangler, H-Man
             

            I guess it's so that they can find it? XD You know like trying to find the end piece of a tape roll, lol.

            •  
              Dysnomia in Singapore [www]
              2010/11/30 17:01
              Registered on 2010/02/09. Digital Media Student
               

              XD then it's kinda weird that such errors happen. Printing onto the end of the paper roll.

              •  
                Lightning Sabre in Vancouver [www]
                2010/12/01 13:36
                Registered on 2007/08/30. Prepress Operator, 触手 wrangler, H-Man
                 

                Ah it's common actually. It depends on how long the run is. Specially since it's an almost 200 page book it needs to use a few rolls to make lots of copies.

    •  
      Marx-Taich0u in Please dun stalk me D:
      2010/12/01 00:06
      Registered on 2010/10/29. Sugar with a side of coffee
       

      I knew I recognize those patterns from the edges of a newspaper and that big badass machine that cuts them. *stalked someone there once lol*

      •  
        Lightning Sabre in Vancouver [www]
        2010/12/01 13:37
        Registered on 2007/08/30. Prepress Operator, 触手 wrangler, H-Man
         

        Apparently the pattern is different for the press that I work at. Ours is more wavy line than jagged :)

  •  
    superunature in USA
    2010/11/30 14:35
    Registered on 2010/09/14. Student
     

    I buy Chinese licensed mangas :P
    $2-3 a piece, certainly saves a lot when buying a full set ~

  •  
    yunamon in OtaCoolTure no Saka [www]
    2010/11/30 15:02
    Registered on 2009/03/31. Knightess of the Pink Republic
     

    I believe it's factory defect...

  •  
    silkhat in Singapore [www]
    2010/11/30 15:22
    Registered on 2010/04/18. Puella Magi
     

    thats a cool rip... lD

  •  
    Chibi Miku in Indonesia & Malaysia [www]
    2010/11/30 15:33
    Registered on 2009/12/24. Student
     

    better than the one who ripped my magazine

  •  
    $tranger in ドイツ
    2010/11/30 15:39
    Registered on 2010/06/08. Madman
     

    Funky rip :P
    So far I've encountered one or two cutting error in books, but nothing major. Too bad that you can't exchange it anymore :/
    I recently had a really annoying problem with a few welcome to the NHK mangas I bought - some genius put the RFID-Stickers (those things that would cause an alert at the shop's entrance) right INTO the book on a random page. Might be great to prevent them from being stolen, but it was impossible to remove that big sticker without ripping the page ><

  •  
    RandomNut in USA
    2010/12/01 15:14
    Registered on 2010/04/29. Grad Student
     

    Its not a rip its where the two roles going into the press meet. The repair is the tape the use to join the two roles together for a continuous feed. They were supposed to remove the split page but its a common error.

    I bet your book was printed by someone who was new to the industry. If you right the publisher they typically will replace the book for free.

  •  
    Desi in United States [www]
    2010/12/02 09:08
    Registered on 2010/06/25. Student, Freelance Artist
     

    I think it's safe to say that this is a simple manufacturing defect. ^^

    A friend of mine once bought me a volume of Loveless whose cover was printed and bound upside-down. ^^;

  •  
    MikuMikuKagamine in the Death Star [www]
    2010/12/27 12:44
    Registered on 2010/06/25. Palpatine's Apprentice (BEST. JOB. EVER.)
     

    I remember when I got Read or Dream #1 from my library...it was like someone took a massive "chomp" out of the page T_T


Latest Posts
Currently being read